According to the American Bankruptcy Institute, Chapter 13 filings accounted for approximately 40% of personal bankruptcies in 2023, providing a comparable solution to IVAs of the UK in managing personal debt in the US.
In the US, there are no IVAs. Instead, Chapter 13 bankruptcy is a similar option, allowing debt restructuring over 3-5 years. In 2023, Chapter 13 filings accounted for about 40% of personal bankruptcies, offering a structured way to manage debt without liquidating assets.
An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) is a legally binding agreement between an individual and their creditors to pay off debt over a set period of time, usually around five years. It's an alternative to bankruptcy, allowing individuals to manage their debt in a structured way while avoiding the more severe consequences of bankruptcy.
The Big Question is that -
Who is an IVA Suitable For?
Individuals with unsecured debts such as credit cards, personal loans, and overdrafts.
Most people in the UK are eligible for IVA.
Those with regular income but struggling to manage debt repayments.
People who are looking for an alternative to bankruptcy while still protecting their assets like a home or car.
Eligibility for an IVA
An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) is a formal agreement with creditors to repay debts over time. It offers an alternative to bankruptcy for those who meet specific eligibility criteria.
Inability to pay monthly debt repayments: You must demonstrate that you cannot meet your current debt obligations.
Debt exceeds assets and home equity: The value of your debt must be greater than your total assets, including home equity.
Consultation with an FCA-authorised adviser: You must seek advice from an adviser authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA).
To qualify for an IVA, you must meet specific eligibility criteria, including demonstrating an inability to repay debts. Once eligibility is confirmed, the IVA process begins with an Insolvency Practitioner, who helps formalise the agreement with creditors, ensuring a structured repayment plan and protection from legal actions.
To check your eligibility for a DMP in the USA, check out Shepherd Outsourcing for more details.
IVA Process
An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) is a formal debt solution in the UK that allows individuals to repay their creditors over time while avoiding the drastic consequences of bankruptcy. Managed by an Insolvency Practitioner (IP), the IVA process involves several key steps.
Step 1: Setup and Consultation
The process begins with a consultation with an Insolvency Practitioner (IP), who evaluates your financial situation. If an IVA is suitable, the IP acts as the nominee and drafts a proposal outlining your monthly payment plan based on your income and living expenses.
In 2023, IVAs accounted for over 60% of individual insolvencies in the UK, highlighting their popularity as a debt solution.
Step 2: Proposal to Creditors
Once the proposal is finalised, it is submitted to all your creditors. The creditors then review the terms and vote on whether to accept the arrangement. For the IVA to be approved, creditors representing 75% of the total debt value must agree.
On average, around 78% of IVA proposals are approved by creditors, offering debtors relief from creditor harassment and legal actions.
Step 3: Creditor Agreement
Once the IVA is approved, it becomes legally binding on all creditors, even those who did not vote in favour. From this point on, creditors can no longer charge interest or take legal action against you for the debts included in the IVA.
Step 4: Monthly Payments
Upon approval, you start making monthly payments to the IP. The IP distributes the money to your creditors based on the agreed terms. Most IVAs run for five years, during which you make consistent payments.
Monthly payments in an IVA generally range from £80 to £250, depending on your disposable income.
Step 5: Fees and Costs
The costs of an IVA typically include:
Nominee Fee: Covers the initial setup of the IVA by the IP.
Supervisor Fee: Covers the ongoing management and distribution of payments to creditors.
These fees are included in the monthly payments, meaning they do not add an extra financial burden.
Step 6: Completion and Debt Write-Off
Once you successfully complete the payment plan, any remaining unsecured debt is written off. This often results in substantial debt reduction, allowing for a fresh start.
In many cases, individuals can have up to 70% of their unsecured debt written off after completing the IVA.
The IVA process offers a structured way to regain control over unmanageable debt, with the help of an Insolvency Practitioner and the protection of a legally binding agreement. However, it requires a commitment to a payment plan and careful consideration of the long-term impact on credit.
Managing Your IVA: Key Considerations
Once an IVA is in place, careful management and adherence to its terms are required to ensure successful completion. While it provides relief from immediate financial pressure, there are several important factors to keep in mind throughout the duration of your IVA.
Regular Payments: You must continue making the agreed monthly or lump-sum payments, which will be used to repay your creditors over time.
Annual Review: Every year, your income and expenditure will be reviewed by your Insolvency Practitioner, with the possibility of adjusting your payments if your financial situation changes.
Restricted Credit Access: You will have limited access to new credit. Borrowing more than £500 requires prior approval from your Insolvency Practitioner.
As your IVA progresses, annual reviews of your finances may lead to adjustments in your payments while credit access remains restricted. Additionally, understanding which debts can be included in your IVA is crucial to ensure the plan addresses your specific financial needs.
Debt Inclusion in an IVA
An IVA allows individuals to include certain types of debt in the repayment plan, while some are excluded due to legal or secured obligations. Understanding what can and cannot be included is crucial when considering an IVA.
Included Debts:
Unsecured debts, such as personal loans, credit card balances, overdrafts, and arrears on bills (like utility and council tax), can be included in an IVA.
Excluded Debts:
Secured debts, like mortgages or car loans, are not included in an IVA.
Specific obligations such as student loans, child support, and court fines also cannot be.
While certain secured debts and specific obligations cannot be included in an IVA, the arrangement still offers substantial benefits for managing unsecured debts.
However, it's important to carefully assess both the advantages and potential risks to determine whether an IVA is the right debt solution for you.
Suggested Read: How Does Debt Consolidation Work?
Benefits and Considerations of an IVA
An Individual Voluntary Arrangement (IVA) provides an effective path to debt management for many individuals, but it’s essential to weigh both the benefits and potential risks before deciding if it’s the right solution.
Benefits:
Creditor Protection: Once approved, creditors cannot take further legal action, providing relief from wage garnishment, lawsuits, or debt collection efforts.
Debt Write-Off: Upon completion, any remaining unsecured debt is written off, offering significant debt relief and a fresh start.
Single Monthly Payment: It simplifies debt repayment by consolidating multiple debts into one affordable monthly payment.
Asset Protection: Unlike bankruptcy, an IVA allows you to protect important assets like your home or car.
Tailored Plan: Payments are based on what you can afford, ensuring that the repayment plan suits your financial situation.
Considerations:
Impact on Credit Score: An IVA remains on your credit report for six years, negatively affecting your ability to obtain credit during and after the IVA.
Potential for Failure: If you fail to keep up with IVA payments, it can lead to bankruptcy, which has more severe financial consequences.
Restricted Access to Credit: During the IVA, you are restricted from borrowing more than £500 without permission from your Insolvency Practitioner.
While an IVA offers many advantages, such as creditor protection and debt write-off, it’s important to understand the risks. Seeking legal and financial advice is strongly recommended to determine if an IVA is the right debt solution for your circumstances.
Debt Management Plans (DMPs) vs. Individual Voluntary Arrangements (IVAs)
Both Debt Management Plans (DMPs) and Individual Voluntary Arrangements (IVAs) are debt solutions designed to help individuals struggling with unmanageable debt, but they differ significantly in terms of their structure, legal standing, and impact. Then,
What is a Debt Management Plan (DMP)?
A DMP is an informal agreement between an individual and their creditors to pay off unsecured debts through manageable monthly payments. It’s often used for debts like credit cards, personal loans, and overdrafts. Managed by a third-party organisation (usually a debt charity or a company), the monthly payments are distributed among creditors. This is usually seen very commonly in the US, although IVAs are more common in the UK. Let’s also briefly compare the two. Before that, let us explore the key features of DMPs.
Key Features of DMPs:
Informal Arrangement: A DMP is not legally binding, so creditors can opt out or change terms at any time.
Flexibility: Payments are based on what the debtor can afford and can be adjusted as financial circumstances change.
No Legal Protection: Creditors can still pursue legal action, charge interest, or add fees.
No Debt Write-Off: DMPs focus solely on repayment, so no part of the debt is written off, and it may take longer to repay all debts.
Credit Impact: While a DMP itself isn't recorded on a credit file, missed or reduced payments to creditors can negatively affect your credit score.
Key Differences Between DMPs and IVAs:
Legal Status:
DMP: Informal and flexible, but not legally binding.
IVA: Legally binding with protection from creditors once agreed.
Debt Write-Off:
DMP: No debts are written off; all debts must be repaid in full.
IVA: Unsecured debts can be partially written off once the IVA term is completed.
Eligibility and Suitability:
DMP: Suitable for people with less severe debt who can afford to repay their debts over time.
IVA: Better suited for individuals with larger debt amounts who cannot repay in full and need a more structured, legally binding solution.
Creditor Involvement:
DMP: Creditors can opt-out, and there is no guarantee they will stop interest or legal actions.
IVA: Once agreed, creditors are bound to stop legal actions and freeze interest.
Length of Agreement:
DMP: The duration depends on the size of the debt and the monthly payments; it could last many years.
IVA: Typically lasts five years, after which any remaining unsecured debt is written off.
Success Rates of DMPs and IVAs
When comparing Debt Management Plans (DMPs) and Individual Voluntary Arrangements (IVAs), statistics show that each option benefits different types of financial situations. Here’s a breakdown based on recent data:
IVAs have a higher completion rate of around 78%, meaning the majority of people successfully complete their agreed payment plan, and their remaining debt is written off. However, 22% of IVAs fail, often due to changing financial circumstances that make payments unaffordable.
DMPs do not have a fixed success rate because they are informal and can be adjusted, but many people find themselves on DMPs for extended periods (sometimes over ten years), as creditors may not agree to stop interest charges or fees. As a result, a DMP might not always provide a clear exit from debt.
Both DMPs and IVAs negatively affect your credit score, but IVAs remain on your credit report for six years, even if the arrangement lasts for a shorter time. DMPs might not show directly on your credit file, but creditors' actions during the DMP (such as missed payments or defaults) will be recorded, impacting your credit similarly.
Ultimately, whether a DMP or an IVA is better depends on your financial situation, the size of your debt, and how much creditor pressure you’re facing. It’s advisable to seek advice from a debt professional to determine the most appropriate solution.
Opmerkingen